Aubel aubel

Three ways in

Start with the version that fits today.

Scale · 2nd mode of major · W H W W W H W

Dorian minor with a raised 6th


Sampled piano. Sound on.

· · ·

The recipe

The easiest place to see Dorian is on a piano: play every white key from D up to D. That is D Dorian. The notes are identical to C major's white keys, but the scale is built around D instead of C, which moves the interval pattern from W W H W W W H (major) to W H W W W H W (Dorian). The position of that interior half step is what defines the mode.

Every mode of the major scale works this way. Start on the 2nd degree and you get Dorian; the 3rd gives Phrygian, the 4th gives Lydian, the 5th gives Mixolydian. Same seven notes, seven different centers, seven different sounds.

On the staff

D Dorian: the white keys D to D, the natural B is the raised 6th

What the raised 6th does

In natural minor the 6th sits a half step above the 5th and tends to fall down to it. That downward gravity is part of what gives natural minor its weight. Dorian raises the 6th by a semitone, putting it a whole step above the 5th. The pull is gone. The scale still has a minor 3rd, so it still reads as minor, but it does not feel like it is grieving.

Where you've heard it

"Scarborough Fair," in E Dorian. The raised 6th, C-sharp instead of C natural, is audible in the melody and is the reason the song does not sound funereal even though it is structurally minor. C&M cites the older "Greensleeves" as Dorian for the same reason.

Miles Davis's "So What." The A section vamps on D Dorian for sixteen bars. Bill Evans's piano voicing under that vamp, stacked fourths, is one of the most copied sounds in jazz, and it is just Dorian harmonized vertically. The link runs both ways in jazz theory: Mark Levine builds the minor 7th chord straight out of Dorian, so a D minor 7th chord and the D Dorian scale are the same seven notes read as a chord or as a scale.

"Eleanor Rigby." The Beatles in E Dorian. Beatles scholars including Alan Pollack and Walter Everett classify it this way, pointing to the raised 6th (C-sharp) in the string accompaniment.

Telling Dorian apart from the other minor modes

Dorian shares a minor 3rd with natural, harmonic, and melodic minor, and with Phrygian and Locrian. The disambiguation is in the surrounding degrees.

Versus natural minor: the raised 6th. If a minor melody hangs on the 6th and that 6th sounds bright rather than mournful, you are in Dorian. Versus Phrygian: the 2nd degree. Phrygian's 2nd is a half step above the root and reads as flamenco; Dorian's 2nd is a whole step away and stays neutral. Versus melodic minor: both raise the 6th, but melodic minor also raises the 7th, so if the leading tone pulls hard to the tonic you are hearing melodic. Dorian leaves the 7th flat, which is part of why it feels modal rather than pointed at home.

How Aubel handles it

Dorian is the first of the modes to unlock, the fifth scale overall, after the major, natural-minor, harmonic-minor, and melodic-minor foundation. By the time you meet it you have already drilled the minor 3rd against the major 3rd, which is the distinction Dorian leans on for its identity. The new thing to catch is its bright 6th, the one note that lifts it out of plain minor. Rounds play the full scale up and down from a random root, so you learn the color, not a key.

Common questions

What is the Dorian mode?
A minor scale with one note changed: the 6th degree is raised a semitone. That makes it the brightest of the minor-family scales. It is also the 2nd mode of the major scale: play the white keys from D to D and you have D Dorian, the same notes as C major but centered on D. Its step pattern is W H W W W H W.
What is the difference between Dorian and natural minor?
A single degree: the 6th. Natural minor has a flat 6th that sits a half step above the 5th and tends to sag downward. Dorian raises that 6th to a whole step above the 5th, removing the downward pull. Both are minor and share the flat 3rd, but Dorian sounds open and level where natural minor sounds heavier.
Why does Dorian sound brighter than minor?
The raised 6th. In natural minor the flat 6th leans down toward the 5th, which is part of what gives the scale its weight. Dorian lifts that note a semitone, and the gravity goes away. The scale still reads as minor because the 3rd is flat, but it no longer sounds like it is grieving. It sounds modal and steady.
What songs are in Dorian?
Scarborough Fair, in E Dorian, where the raised 6th (C-sharp) keeps the tune from sounding funereal. Miles Davis’s "So What" vamps on D Dorian for sixteen bars. The Beatles’ "Eleanor Rigby" is widely analyzed as E Dorian, the raised 6th audible in the strings.

References

Train this in Aubel.

Aubel is free to download, pay what you want. Recognize intervals, scales, chords, and intonation by ear, and read them on the page, in the browser and on iPhone.

Get Aubel on the App Store