Aubel aubel

Three ways in

Start with the version that fits today.

Scale · 3rd mode of major · H W W W H W W

Phrygian minor with a flat 2nd


Sampled piano. Sound on.

· · ·

The half step that defines it

Phrygian is natural minor with its 2nd degree flattened. In plain minor the 2nd is a whole step above the tonic, a neutral, stepwise move. Phrygian pulls it down to a half step, so the very first interval of the scale is the tightest one there is, the 2nd leaning hard into the root. Everything dark about the mode comes from that one move.

On the piano it is the white keys from E to E: the 3rd mode of the major scale, C major's notes centered on E. The half step between E and F, sitting right at the bottom of the scale, is the flat 2nd. It is also why the step pattern, uniquely, begins with a half step: H W W W H W W.

On the staff

E Phrygian: the white keys E to E, the F just above E is the flat 2nd

The Spanish and the heavy

Two traditions live on this sound. Flamenco is built on Phrygian harmony: its cadences descend toward a tonic with that flat 2nd leaning in from above, and the result is the sound most listeners label "Spanish." Much flamenco actually raises the 3rd to major, the related Phrygian dominant scale, but the dark, half-step-above-tonic frame underneath is pure Phrygian.

The other home is metal. The flat 2nd makes a menacing, tense riff almost for free, so Phrygian and Phrygian dominant turn up constantly in heavy music. In both cases the cue your ear is hunting for is the same: a minor scale whose second note sits a half step above the root rather than a whole step. That is the whole identification.

Jazz puts the mode to a less obvious use. Mark Levine notes that players usually take Phrygian not over a minor 7th chord but over a sus♭9 chord, where the mode's flat 2nd becomes the chord's defining flat 9th.

How Aubel handles it

Phrygian unlocks eighth, the fourth of the modes and the last of the minor-family ones. By now your ear is fluent in the minor 3rd, so the question Phrygian poses is narrow: where is the 2nd? Dorian raised the 6th; Phrygian lowers the 2nd. Listen to the very start of the scale. If the second note crowds the tonic, you have it. Rounds play the scale ascending and descending from a random root, so the cue you train is that low 2nd itself.

Common questions

What is the Phrygian mode?
A minor scale with one note changed: the 2nd degree is lowered a semitone, so it sits just a half step above the tonic. That flat 2nd is the darkest, most distinctive sound in the scale. Phrygian is the 3rd mode of the major scale, the white keys from E to E, and its step pattern is H W W W H W W, starting with that half step.
What is the difference between Phrygian and natural minor?
One degree: the 2nd. Natural minor’s 2nd is a whole step above the tonic and sounds neutral. Phrygian drops it to a half step above, right up against the root. Both are minor and share the flat 3rd, 6th, and 7th, but that low 2nd gives Phrygian a tense, exotic darkness that plain minor does not have.
Why does Phrygian sound Spanish?
The flat 2nd. Flamenco is built on Phrygian harmony, and its signature cadence, chords descending to a tonic with that half step above it leaning in, is the sound most people hear as "Spanish." The half-step-above-the-tonic motion is the fingerprint. Listen for the second note of the scale sitting tightly over the first.
What is the difference between Phrygian and Phrygian dominant?
Phrygian dominant, the "Spanish gypsy" scale heard in much flamenco and metal, raises the 3rd degree to major while keeping the flat 2nd. That gives it a major-sounding chord over a dark, half-step-above-tonic root. Plain Phrygian keeps the minor 3rd. If the 3rd sounds bright over that low 2nd, you are hearing Phrygian dominant, not Phrygian.

References

Train this in Aubel.

Aubel is free to download, pay what you want. Recognize intervals, scales, chords, and intonation by ear, and read them on the page, in the browser and on iPhone.

Get Aubel on the App Store