Aubel aubel

Three ways in

Start with the version that fits today.

Scale · W H W W H W W · the plain minor

Natural Minor the plain minor


Sampled piano. Sound on.

· · ·

What gets lowered

Against a major scale on the same tonic, natural minor flattens three degrees: the 3rd, the 6th, and the 7th. The lowered 3rd is the big one. It is the note that flips the scale from major to minor, and it is the first thing to listen for. The lowered 6th and 7th do quieter work: they pull the top of the scale away from the octave, so instead of leaning home the way major does, natural minor settles in sideways.

The step pattern is W H W W H W W. Notice the half steps land between the 2nd and 3rd degrees and between the 5th and 6th, different places than major, which is exactly why the two scales feel so different even though five of their notes are shared.

The relative-minor trick

Natural minor and major are two views of the same set of notes. The white keys from C to C are C major; the same white keys from A to A are A natural minor. They share a key signature and every pitch. Only the starting note, and so the center of gravity, has moved. That is what "relative" means: A minor is the relative minor of C major.

The practical shortcut falls out of this. The 6th degree of any major scale is the tonic of its relative minor, which is three semitones down. It is worth internalizing because it means every minor scale you learn is a major scale you already know, re-centered.

On the staff

A natural minor: the white keys, A to A
C natural minor: flat 3rd, 6th, 7th

The missing leading tone

The single most useful thing to hear in natural minor is what is not there. Major and harmonic minor both have a leading tone, a 7th degree a half step under the octave that strains upward into it. Natural minor flattens that 7th to a full whole step below the tonic. The approach to the top of the scale goes slack. That looseness is the tell: a minor scale that arrives at the octave smoothly, without a final half-step snap, is natural minor (or the descending side of melodic minor, which is the same thing).

Kostka and Payne suggest a cleaner way to hold the three minor scales in mind: think of them as one minor scale with a variable 6th and 7th. A composer raises or lowers those two degrees as a line climbs or falls; natural minor is simply the form with both left low.

It is also why so much folk and rock writing prefers it. Functional classical harmony wants the leading tone to drive cadences, so it reaches for harmonic minor. A modal pop song that just wants the color of minor, without being pulled toward a resolution, stays in natural minor.

How Aubel handles it

Natural minor is one of the two scales the Scales game starts with, alongside major. They are paired on purpose: the first skill the game trains is hearing the minor 3rd against the major 3rd, which is the foundation every later scale leans on. Rounds play the full scale up and down from a random root, so you learn the shape rather than one key. Clear the starting pair and harmonic minor unlocks next, the same scale with the leading tone added back.

Common questions

What is the natural minor scale?
The plain minor scale: a major scale with the 3rd, 6th, and 7th degrees each lowered a semitone. Its step pattern is W H W W H W W. The lowered 3rd is what makes it minor; the lowered 6th and 7th are what make it natural minor rather than one of the altered minor forms. It is also the Aeolian mode, the scale you get by playing the white keys from A to A.
What is the difference between natural, harmonic, and melodic minor?
Only the top two degrees. Natural minor leaves the 6th and 7th flat. Harmonic minor raises the 7th to make a leading tone, which leaves a wide, exotic-sounding gap up to it. Melodic minor raises both the 6th and 7th to smooth that gap out. The lower half of all three is identical, so the differences live entirely in how the scale approaches the octave.
What is the relative minor?
Every major scale has a natural-minor scale that uses exactly the same notes, starting three semitones lower. C major and A natural minor are both the white keys; they are relatives. The shortcut: the 6th degree of a major scale is the tonic of its relative minor, so counting down three semitones from any major tonic lands you on it.
Why does natural minor sound unresolved compared to major?
It has no leading tone. In major, the 7th sits a half step below the octave and pulls sharply up into it. Natural minor flattens that 7th to a whole step below the tonic, the "subtonic," so the pull is gone. The scale arrives gently rather than snapping home, which is the modal, open quality folk and rock writers reach for when they want minor without the classical tension.

References

Train this in Aubel.

Aubel is free to download, pay what you want. Recognize intervals, scales, chords, and intonation by ear, and read them on the page, in the browser and on iPhone.

Get Aubel on the App Store